What We Do
Practice Area
Tax
"A world-class service provider and a key partner in analysing our tax issues."
Chambers Europe 2011
Our tax department is significantly the largest tax practice group amongst Irish law firms. In contrast to the tax departments of other Irish law firms, we operate primarily as a “front-end” service. Significantly more than half of our work is on transactions or advisory matters where our tax professionals have the sole or lead role. We also advise on the taxation aspects of transactions as part of a multi-disciplinary team with lawyers from other groups within the firm. We often act as special tax counsel in transactions where clients require specialised tax advice and are not comfortable using the tax department of their existing legal advisers. We do not provide Tax compliance services.
We are the only Irish law firm to have a dedicated international tax group, which advises on cross-border transactions in conjunction with legal and tax counsel from other jurisdictions, we have committed considerable resources to building and maintaining good relationships with these lawyers.
We advise many leading domestic and international corporations and financial institutions doing business in and through Ireland. We focus on the timely delivery and implementation of integrated leading edge tax advice. Our philosophy is “can do” – if there is a solution we will find it and it will be practicable and capable of being implemented.
We are the only Irish law firm to have Irish tax capability in the United States. In 2011, leading tax adviser John Ryan, was appointed head of the firm’s US offices. Since June 2011, John has been based in the firm's office in New York.
We are consistently ranked as the leading tax law firm in Ireland by the European Legal 500, Chambers Global, PLC Which Lawyer?, American Lawyer, Directors Tax Handbook, World Tax and International Tax Review.
Our Tax Group advises in relation to:
- General Corporate Tax
We advise leading Irish and international companies across all industries with respect to their inward investment into Ireland, international tax and cross-border planning, corporate reorganisations and restructurings, M&A, demergers, flotation’s, private equity and joint ventures.
- Transfer Pricing
We are the only law firm in Ireland with a significant transfer pricing practice. Examples of our work in this area include advising on the first transfer pricing adjustment completed under Irish law, the first multi-lateral transfer pricing adjustment completed under Irish law, and the ground-breaking claim by a non-treaty resident company to correlative relief under an Irish tax treaty. We acted for a number of US multinationals in connection with the judgment of the US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal in Xilinx v CIR.
- Finance Tax
Our finance tax practice covers a broad spectrum of debt based work including banking, structured finance, securitisation, repackaging, debt capital markets, asset finance, project finance and derivatives.
In league tables published each year since 2005 by international financial publisher, Thomson Reuters , Matheson Ormsby Prentice was recognised as having advised more issuers of specialist debt securities in international debt issuance transactions than any other law firm in Europe.
- VAT and Indirect Tax
We provide both contentious and advisory VAT advice. We act on a broad range of cases including appeals before the Appeal Commissioners, judicial review applications to the High Court, appeals to the Supreme Court and cases before the European courts. Contentious matters range from the establishment of the VAT treatment for invoice discounting and factoring in Ireland, the application of VAT to various property structures, the Customs Duty classification of internet security devices and the defending of claims for Customs Duty on withdrawal of GSP preference. On the advisory side, we advise on VAT compliance and structuring in a wide range of industries, including financial services, property, retail, travel agency, software and aerospace.
- Real Estate Tax
Although primarily focused on general corporate and finance related work, our tax department provides a full range of taxation advisory services to our many clients doing business in and through Ireland. This includes real estate taxation, where we act for various consortia of Irish investors in relation to acquisitions and disposals of commercial property portfolios, and also development and financing.
- Tax Controversy and Tax Litigation
We have extensive experience in conducting tax controversy work including Revenue negotiations and tax efficient dispute resolution. We have been involved in some recent high profile tax litigation in the High Court. Certain contentious tax work does not proceed to litigation.
- Irish Tax Capability in the United States
We are the only Irish law firm to have Irish tax capability in the United States. In June 2011, John Ryan, who is widely acknowledged as one of Ireland’s leading international tax advisers, re-located to the firm’s New York office. John has more than 20 years’ experience advising international companies doing business in and through Ireland. He leads a team of tax, corporate and financial services lawyers based in the firm’s US offices, which focuses on advising US companies and financial institutions doing business in and through Ireland.
As tax is a sensitive and confidential topic for many clients, in many cases we are unable to give specific details of particular projects we have undertaken. However, our experience in recent transactions includes advising companies in the following sectors;
- finance and insurance
- pharmaceutical
- fast moving consumer goods
- technology
- contract catering
- energy
- utilities
- transport
- healthcare
- chemical
- real estate
- manufacturing
We have also advised on the tax aspects of a significant number of private corporate transactions (including certain buy-outs of high-value minority positions and transactions to transfer high-value family-owned businesses to the next generation).
Some of our recent public transactions in the area of Tax Controversy and Tax Litigation include:
- advising a major bank in relation to regulatory inquiries ongoing since 1998 in relation to its banking activities
- advising various US multinationals on the implications of the Xilinx case before the US Ninth Circuit (judgment subsequently reversed by the US Ninth Circuit)
- representing National Irish Bank in its successful challenge to the Revenue Commissioners on obtaining information held by its Isle of Man branch (currently on appeal to the Supreme Court)
- advising leading investment banks in respect of stamp duty investigations initiated by the Revenue Commissioners
- representing RSA Security Systems in its application to the European Court of First Instance, seeking the annulment of EU Commission Regulation 888/2006
- representing Hagemeyer Ireland plc in its successful judicial review proceedings before the High Court overturning the previous Revenue practice in relation to the VAT treatment of invoice discounting and factoring operations
This firm's standalone tax group has a strong identity on the market and offers strength in depth when it comes to skill and quantity of lawyers. Clients rate it as "a world-class service provider and a key partner in analysing our tax issues."
Tax: Chambers Global 2011
Tax: Chambers Global 2011
Matheson Ormsby Prentice has the largest tax practice of any law firm in Ireland. The firm's VAT team and practitioners with transfer pricing knowledge give the firm the ability to assist companies on a wider range of tax issues, not just corporate and finance. The firm's tax group advised Xilinx Ireland in a transfer pricing case concerning the cost-sharing arrangement between it and its parent company in California. Some described the case as the most significant in its field in the US in the last 20 years.
World Tax 2011
World Tax 2011
Matheson Ormsby Prentice offers “a premier tax service – the firm has excellent reach into the relevant legislative and commercial bodies and, technically, the level of sophistication in its advice is very high.” The practice is comprehensive, but it is particularly noted for its expertise within both VAT and finance-related tax.
Tax: Chambers Global 2010
Tax: Chambers Global 2010
Matheson Ormsby Prentice "represents Big Four quality standards", attracting praise for its "solutions-oriented philosophy" and for "proactively constructing transactions to meet business objectives".
Tax: European Legal 500 2010
Tax: European Legal 500 2010
Comfortably the largest tax department in Ireland, this group’s “sheer size is always a talking point, but the partners live and breathe tax as well. They’re commercially aware and give straightforward advice.” Several commentators also remarked that the firm’s New York and Palo Alto offices give the team an edge when it comes to winning new business. This is a “creative and technically excellent practice,” where the lawyers are “a pleasure to work with and will always respond to your queries no matter how unreasonable the hour.”
Tax: Chambers Europe 2009
Tax: Chambers Europe 2009
The tax team at Matheson Ormsby Prentice leads the market in terms of size and clients. Put simply: "you can involve them in practically any international tax issue".
Tax: European Legal 500 2009
Tax: European Legal 500 2009
“Quick to respond and eager to find solutions to problems”
Tax: Chambers Global 2009
Tax: Chambers Global 2009
The ‘all-star’ team at Matheson Ormsby Prentice continues to dominate the tax market in Ireland and is widely perceived as ‘the go-to firm’ for tax advice. The firm boasts unrivalled depth and breadth across the board and has specialist capability in inward investment, cross-border planning, M&A, restructuring, transfer pricing and finance tax.
Tax: European Legal 500 2008
Tax: European Legal 500 2008
This “top quality” tax practice remains the largest in Ireland by some distance, offering clients a “very impressive” mix of lawyers, barristers and advisers. The firm also has a dedicated VAT and indirect tax practice to advise on the full scope of indirect tax issues. “Efficient, proactive, commercially aware and affective in its advice on transactional matters”, the team handles a broad range on work including structured finance and capital markets, cross-border tax planning, inward investment, corporate restructuring and transfer pricing …the lawyers were particularly commended for their enterprise at recognising the unique needs of multinational clients.
Tax: Chambers Europe 2008
Tax: Chambers Europe 2008
Matheson Ormsby Prentice’s tax practice has a list of characteristics that makes it stand out.
World Tax 2008
World Tax 2008
Matheson Ormsby Prentice’s tax team continues to supply tax advice that is often both complex and ground-breaking in nature. It remains the ‘go-to firm’ for tax services.
Tax Directors Handbook 2008
Tax Directors Handbook 2008
